Who embroidered the handkerchief?
May 20th, 2007 by Jill HallLast time I mentioned that the embroidered handkerchief is being used as a gift in the courtship story in the 1627 English Village. An inquisitive reader (thanks, Amy) asked who would have done the embroidery?
It is very unlikely that much, if any, embroidery was being carried out in Plymouth Colony’s early years. The business of growing, preserving and preparing food occupied a great deal of time. The fact that there was not yet a grist mill for grinding grain into meal meant that hours upon hours of labor were spent grinding grain in a mortar and pestle. Even though at least some of the women living in Plymouth in 1627 must have known some embroidery, we don’t think they were spending any time on it, so the handkerchief must have been brought into the colony.
Like so much else, the specifics of courtship in 1620s New Plymouth were unrecorded. We know that Isaac Allerton traveled to England on the colony’s business in the summer of 1626, returning to Plymouth Colony in the spring of 1627. The written records allude to Allerton bringing items ‘on his own particular’ (or outside his capacity as the colony’s representative) to sell to his fellow colonists, but the record is annoyingly non-specific.
We also know, from inventories of itinerant peddlers, that small, relatively inexpensive embroidered items were available in England ready-made. We’re putting those two bits of information together and ‘interpreting’, or making a reasonable leap from known facts, that this handkerchief was one of the items Allerton brought back ‘on his particular’, and that the suitor purchased it from Allerton.
So who embroidered the handkerchief? It’s possible that professional workshops like those that produced the embroidered jackets also made smaller articles like handkerchiefs. It’s possible that independent embroiderers made items for sale. We know that the professionals in the workshops were mostly men; we don’t know if women embroidered for sale or how or if they were organized in any way. The records of the Embroiderers’ Guild were lost in the London Fire of 1666. What light they might have shed on all these questions we’ll never know. The good news, though, is that modern scholars are continually dredging deeper and deeper into the records that have come down to us. In future posts I’ll be describing some of the many books we’ve been reading as part of our research for this project.
Costume historian Susan Vincent in Clothing the Elite wrote that searching for information on the clothing of the past is like “looking for salt in the sea – the evidence is everywhere, and nowhere.” Sometimes bits of information come from very unlikely sources. If you know of obscure articles or books, or scraps of knowledge hiding in books about other topics, I’d be glad to learn of them. Perhaps through this project and blog we can enlarge the body of knowledge on this topic, to the good of all.



ceremony – coincidently on June 20th – so if you come to embroider you can see it in person.